Chemistry in Action 50

A Round-up of Carbon chemistry

(Reprinted by permission from
Chemistry in Britain, 1996, 32(9) 34-35)

MUSICMATCH 9 REGISTRATION KEY

The discovery of C60, and shortly afterwards a whole series of other fullerenes, was greeted with near disbelief. Not until Huffman and Kr„tschmer's paper was published did chemists finally agree to rewrite the textbooks. From then on, they have had to rethink radically their ideas about carbon chemistry.
The first step was to try and understand the chemistry of these molecules: how do they react; what compounds can be made from them; and, equally, important, what applications might they have? To begin with, chemists tried to draw analogies with conventional carbon chemistry. For C60 the obvious comparison was with the archetypal ring molecule benzene. It was a poor fit. Unlike the aromatic, stabilising, ring current of benzene, C60, was found to contain two opposing ring currents that cancel each other out. Rather, C60, is an electron deficient electron acceptor, which rapidly decomposes in the presence of light and trace amounts of ozone in the air.
On the face of it, this was good news. As a 'super alkene', chemists reckoned, C60 should be a precursor for a wealth of potentially useful compounds. The problem of targeting addition across a 60-atom structure was challenge they couldn't resist.
Several groups set about the task of taming these reactions. The Sussex group focused on selective halogenations. Independently, researchers at DuPont also made significant advances in this area and the resulting halides became important intermediates in a variety of chemical reactions, paving the way for a whole series of fullerene derivatives based on substitution of bromine by a variety of other groups such as phenyl and methoxy.
Work by John Holloway at the University of Leicester, along with several other groups, to produce selectively the potentially more readily substituted, low fluorine content, fluorofullerenes proved more difficult. Only recently have researchers begun to overcome some of the problems inherent in such reactions, with the publication in 1996 of a paper by Roger Taylor at Sussex and Olga Boltalina at Moscow State University, describing the preparation of C60F36-38.
Polymer chemists were quick to get in on the game. In the early 1990s chemists at Sandia in New Mexico successfully prepared the first C60 copolymer, by reacting the diradical xylylene with C60. Although there are no foreseeable applications for such fullerene polymers in the short term, one polymer comprising C60 and Pd atoms is showing promise for catalysing hydrogenation reactions.

Organometallic chemists have also had a field day with the fullerenes, producing osmium, platinum and iridium derivatives among others. And while conventional chemistry might have limited them to attaching metals on the outside, the unique spherical shape of the fullerenes has also enabled them to prepare a series of metal-encapsulating derivatives, including La@C60, La@C82 and Sc2@C84. Work is also under way to try and encapsulate small molecules such as carbon monoxide and there is speculation about the possibility of using such cages as delivery vehicles for drugs and radioactive nucleides, or as miniature sensors.
There is an interesting reverse scenario. Researchers at the University of California at Santa Barbara led by Fred Wudl have discovered that the soluble fullerene derivative di(phenylethylamino-succinate) fulleroid inhibits the enzyme HIV-1 protease, a key enzyme in the human immuno-deficiency virus, by sitting snugly in the enzyme's active site. Even more startling, researchers at Emory University in Atlanta have since found that the same derivative is also active against another HIV enzyme, reverse transcriptase. Unlike the anti-AIDS drug AZT, which is only effective against acutely infected cells, the C60 derivative also inhibits reproduction of HIV in cells chronically infected with HIV.
But perhaps the biggest surprise of the newly emerging field of fullerene chemistry was the finding by Robert Haddon and colleagues at AT&T Bell Laboratories (Chem.Br. September 1994, 746), that alkali metal salts of C60 are superconductors. In particular, the group reported in a March 1991 issue of Nature, that the potassium fulleride salt K3C60 has the high superconducting temperature (Tc) of 18K. Soon afterwards, Katsumi Tanigaki in Japan raised the Tc for superconducting fullerides even higher, with Cs2RbC60 having a Tc of 33k. The current record, set by Otto Zhou and colleagues of Bell Laboratories in the US, stands at 40K for Cs3C60 - ever nearer to the 77K target desirable for commercial applications. Theoretically the potential of such superconductors is enormous - with possible uses from Maglev trains to MRI magnets. Before fullerene superconductors become commercially viable, however, chemists must also overcome problems of reactivity in air; K3C60 is pyrophoric and the thin films quickly lose their conductivity. Nevertheless, there is growing confidence that chemical modification will lead to more robust materials that may find some novel applications as lightweight electric motors and electromagnets.
Equally promising is the potential of so-called bucky tubes - elongated pipelines of hexagonal carbon faces capped at both ends with the requisite 12 pentagons needed for curvature. Physicist Roger Bacon first observed these unusual 'carbon whiskers' in the 1960s, but it was Sumio Iijima in Japan who first appreciated their significance in terms of fullerene structure in1991. Others have also been quick to appreciate their potential. Carbon nanotubes are predicted to be stronger than any known material (even diamond), with potential applications in numerous nanoscale architectures such as microelectronics. In 1992 Iijima's NEC colleagues Thomas Ebbesen and Pulickel Ajayan brought this prospect a step closer by perfecting a way of making bulk quantities of single-walled nanotubes. Using this material, Iijima and Ajayan later found a way of filling the tubes with molten lead through a mechanism not unlike that of capillary action. The possibility of using such filled tubes as molecular scale wires is attracting considerable interest, fuelled by the observation that at below about 7K lead becomes superconducting.
And the explosion of interest in fullerene chemistry does not stop there. Chemists at DuPont, for example, have recently produced even more novel forms of carbon: carbon 'sea urchins' comprising central cores of gadolinium carbide from which radiate carbon nanotubes; and 'nanoworms' made of a palladium crystal head and a segmented tail of carbon tubes.
Like their counterparts in the world of conventional carbon chemistry, some of these fullerene compounds have also been found to occur as isomers. The first example of a chiral fullerene, C76, was reported in 1991 - a joint effort between Patrick Fowler and David Manolopoulos at the University of Nottingham and Francoise Diederich and Robert Whetten at the University of California in Los Angeles. Shortly after Manolopoulos had predicted the chirality of C76, Diederich produced the corresponding 19-line 13C NMR spectrum. Since then chemists have discovered one chiral form of C78 and have found out that C84 occurs as two different forms, though these have yet to be isolated.
But perhaps even more surprising is the revelation that C60 has been around on the Earth since the end of the Mesozoic era - formed among the black soot that enveloped the Earth as a result of whatever global catastrophe wiped out the dinosaurs 65 million years ago. The question is. of course, how it got there.
Recent investigations of meteorites are providing us with some clues. Since 1994, researchers claim to have been observing the characteristic signatures of C60+ and C70+ in meteorites, and early in 1996 researchers at the Scripps Institute of Oceanography in California reported finding C60-entrapped He in a 2000m year-old meteor impact crater at Sudbury in Ontario. The ratios of He-3 to He-4 in these samples match the interstellar ratios found in meteorites and interplanetary dust particles, lending support to the extraterrestrial origins of these organic molecules.
The other explanation (though the isotopic ratios are inconsistent) is that the fullerenes may have been formed during the intense heat resulting from impact. Whatever the answer, making fullerenes is a lot simpler than we first thought. Forget the expensive lasers, or even the bell jar apparatus. More recent research shows that we have probably all made C60 in the soot of a Bunsen burner flame at some time or another - only its reactivity with air has prevented us from finding it any sooner...


The story continues ...
It is hard to keep up with the chemistry of fullerenes, as the papers keep on flooding out. There is also a considerable presence of the Internet and Chemistry & Industry produced a useful digest of resources - Buckyballs - lining up for the Net - in November 1996 at their web site (
http://ci.mond.org). This provides links into many bucky ball sites.
Diamond, graphite and the fullerenes are all forms of carbon - carbon allotropes - and are quite different in their structures, and in their physical and chemical properties. Diamond has a 3-dimensional network structure (sp3), graphite has a 2 dimensional layer structure (sp2) and C60 and the other fullerenes are molecules (sp2) and form molecular solids: in solid C60 the spherical molecules form a FCC lattice. Is there a missing allotrope? There have been several reports of a polymeric form of carbon based on sp hybridisation with -CðC-Cð chains.


Created by:

Stephen Childs
9312668@ul.ie

Copyright © 1995,1996 Chemistry in Action
Most recent revision 1st October 1997